Publications by category
Journal articles
Smart C, Newman C, Hartill L, Bunce S, McCormick J (2022). Workload effects of online consultation implementation from a Job-Characteristics Model perspective: a qualitative study.
BJGP Open,
7(1), BJGPO.2022.0024-BJGPO.2022.0024.
Abstract:
Workload effects of online consultation implementation from a Job-Characteristics Model perspective: a qualitative study
BackgroundOnline consultation (OC) was previously promoted by the NHS to solve primary care workload challenges. Its implementation was sped up during the COVID-19 pandemic. Workload effects are widely debated. Using a job design perspective may enhance understandings of workload effect.AimTo qualitatively interrogate the workload experiences of primary care staff involved in OC implementation, using the Job Characteristics Model (JCM) to enable the following: a clearer understanding of the primary care staff psychological experiences; and recommendations informing the design of digital implementations and continued use.Design & settingA qualitative interview study of GP practices using OC within South West England.MethodThirteen participants representing seven practices completed JCM-based semi-structured telephone interviews. An abductive theoretically driven thematic analysis was completed.ResultsParticipants experienced different tasks pre- and post-implementation of OC, and adapted differently to them. Differences included the following: contact modality change, some administrative staff felt removed from patient contact; and in perceived autonomy, some GPs valued increased workload control. Variation in workload experience was affected by job role and practice context, and the form of and rationale for implementation. Use of a psychological model (the JCM) allowed clearer consideration of the effects of change, as well as OC on workload.ConclusionPsychological theory may be helpful in interpreting workload effects of technology implementation such as OC. Designing change to include consideration of technology effects, psychological experiences, differences across roles, and individual and practice contexts may be important for technology implementation and evaluation of its workload effects.
Abstract.
MacLeod AM, Smart C, Keohane P, Dallos R, Cox KJ (2022). “We're entitled to be parents just like normal people”: a multiperspective interpretative phenomenological analysis of a mother with a learning disability's experience of parenting following the removal of her older children.
British Journal of Learning Disabilities,
51(3), 368-378.
Abstract:
“We're entitled to be parents just like normal people”: a multiperspective interpretative phenomenological analysis of a mother with a learning disability's experience of parenting following the removal of her older children
AbstractBackgroundDespite a growing body of literature about parents with learning disabilities; there is a paucity of research about experiences of parenting after the removal of a child/children. This study aimed to fill this gap, examining the experiences of that parenting in this context.MethodA multiperspective interpretative phenomenological analysis approach was used. Semistructured interviews were conducted with a parent with a learning disability and three professionals who worked alongside her.FindingsMultiple factors were identified as key changes which enabled the parent to maintain care of her son. The effort from the parent and professionals, understanding of the parent's past experiences and learning disability, and offering her opportunities to develop and illustrate parenting skills were all key to successful parenting after a removal; underpinned by the connection between the parent and professionals.ConclusionFindings highlighted the complex, systemic, and relational nature of these experiences. A formulation‐based approach is needed to support parents with learning disabilities in this context.
Abstract.
Gaussen K, Stedmon J, Smart C (2021). ‘Many pieces one family’: an elaboration of one family’s bereavement experiences. Human Systems Therapy Culture and Attachments, 2(1), 3-19.
Clancy D, Mitchell A, Smart C (2020). A qualitative exploration of the experiences of students attending interprofessional Schwartz Rounds in a University context.
JOURNAL OF INTERPROFESSIONAL CARE,
34(3), 287-296.
Author URL.
Smart C, Page G, Shankar R, Newman C (2020). Keep safe: the when, why and how of epilepsy risk communication.
Seizure,
78, 136-149.
Abstract:
Keep safe: the when, why and how of epilepsy risk communication.
PURPOSE: Risk communication between clinicians and people with epilepsy (PWE) and their families is under researched. There is limited guidance about when and how to have these discussions. This paper explores the current evidence on quality of risk related conversations in epilepsy and suggests a concept of an evidence-based guideline for person centred structured risk communication. METHODS: a literature search of four electronic database, Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase, PUBMED, and CINAHL, was conducted by two independent reviewers using relevant search terms following the principals of the PRISMA guidance. No limits were applied. Supplementary searches included using backwards and forwards citation searching. A predesigned inclusion and exclusion criteria was administered to the identified results. RESULTS: from 376 results identified, 17 studies met the final criteria of which ten were quantitative, five qualitative and two mixed methods. Perspectives of PWE and clinicians were represented. Extracted data was clustered into three domains: communication initiation (e.g. timing, individual tailoring); communication methods (preference for face to face with neurologists); and communication content (acknowledging the anxiety produced by risk communication, the benefits of being self-aware, normalising risk etc.). No papers focused on conversation structure (e.g. helpful phrases), or the best locations to hold conversations. CONCLUSION: More research is needed to develop structured communication of risk. An attempt has been made to put current evidence into this format. Clearer guidance will enhance clinicians' confidence in communicating person centred epilepsy risk with PWE and their families thus improving outcomes.
Abstract.
Author URL.
Quinn C, Byng R, Shenton D, Smart C, Michie S, Stewart A, Taylor R, Maguire M, Harris T, Shaw J, et al (2018). The feasibility of following up prisoners, with mental health problems, after release: a pilot trial employing an innovative system, for engagement and retention in research, with a harder-to-engage population.
Trials,
19(1).
Abstract:
The feasibility of following up prisoners, with mental health problems, after release: a pilot trial employing an innovative system, for engagement and retention in research, with a harder-to-engage population.
BACKGROUND: Following up released prisoners is demanding, particularly for those prisoners with mental health problems, for whom stigma and chaotic lifestyles are problematic. Measurement of mental health outcomes after release is challenging. To evaluate mental healthcare for offender populations, using high-quality randomised controlled trials, evidenced-based methods must be developed to engage them while in custody, to locate and re-interview them after release, and to collect potentially stigmatising mental health outcomes data. METHODS: We developed an initial theoretical model and operational procedures for collecting baseline and follow-up data informed by a literature search, focus groups, and case studies. Male prisoners from five prisons in two sites were invited to participate. The inclusion criteria included individuals who were above threshold on nine-item Patient Health Questionnaire, seven-item Generalized Anxiety Disorder, or post-traumatic stress disorder scales, or who had reported mental health problems in the past 2 years or had been assessed with a likely personality disorder. Potential participants were interviewed to generate baseline data and were re-contacted before their release. We then contacted them for a follow-up interview, which included repeating the earlier data collection measures 2-8 weeks after release. A qualitative formative process evaluation produced and refined a model procedure for the recruitment and retention of male prison leavers in trials, identified the mechanisms which promoted engagement and retention, and mapped these against a theoretical behaviour change model. RESULTS: We developed a flexible procedure which was successful in recruiting male prison leavers to a pilot trial: 185/243 (76%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 70-81%) of those approached agreed to participate. We also retained 63% (95% CI 54-71%) of those eligible to participate in a follow-up interview 2-8 weeks after release. Mental health outcomes data was collected at both these time points. CONCLUSIONS: it is possible to design acceptable procedures to achieve sustained engagement critical for delivering and evaluating interventions in prison and in the community and to collect mental health outcomes data. These procedures may reduce attrition bias in future randomised controlled trials of mental health interventions for prison leavers. This procedure has been replicated and successfully delivered in a subsequent pilot trial and a definitive randomised controlled trial.
Abstract.
Author URL.
Smart C, Froomberg N, Auburn T (2018). What a discursive understanding of interprofessional team meetings might reveal: an exploration of intellectual (learning) disability managers’ performances.
Journal of Interprofessional Care,
32(6), 689-698.
Abstract:
What a discursive understanding of interprofessional team meetings might reveal: an exploration of intellectual (learning) disability managers’ performances
Clinical and academic understandings of interprofessional working are focused mainly on individual factors such as knowledge about different professional roles, and organisational opportunities for interprofessional working (IPW). Less research has examined what happens between people at an interactional level, that is, how interprofessional working is conducted in everyday face-to-face interactions in clinical practice. The current paper proposes a discursive framework for understanding what constitutes IPW in interprofessional meetings at this interactional level. Clinical effectiveness meetings held in intellectual (learning) disability services were used as an example site for IPW. The analysis explored how agenda change points were negotiated, appropriate as agenda change points require collaboration (or agreement) between practitioners to progress to the next point the study found changes in agenda points were accomplished by practitioners conjointly through using discursive strategies including closing questions, and resources such as professional identity and laughter. The agenda provided a frame for the institutional order of the meetings, invoking a trajectory towards timely completion. However, this institutional order was at times subordinated to an ‘order of concern’, which seemed to enable challenges by managers to the meeting Chair and the agenda that demonstrated adherence not only to the procedural nature of the meetings, but also to the needs of service users and the services discussed. We suggest discursive strategies, resources, and both institutional orders, and order of concerns might provide a framework for developing future training and research, that is able to illuminate how IPW might be enacted in face-to-face team meetings.
Abstract.
Byrne J, Smart C, Watson G (2017). “I Felt like I Was Being Abused all over Again”: How Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse Make Sense of the Perinatal Period Through Their Narratives.
Journal of Child Sexual Abuse,
26(4), 465-486.
Abstract:
“I Felt like I Was Being Abused all over Again”: How Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse Make Sense of the Perinatal Period Through Their Narratives
Sequelae following child sexual abuse pervade the lives of adult survivors, significantly impacting on pregnancy and childbirth. Symptoms of this distress are recognized, but meanings for women are less understood. This research aimed to examine the meaning for women themselves of the impact of child sexual abuse on experiences of pregnancy, childbirth, and the postnatal period. Taking a critical feminist perspective, three open-ended interviews with three survivors enabled women’s narratives of pregnancy and childbirth to be heard, explored the structure of these narratives, including how experiences were connected, and identified key themes and how selves and others were positioned. Women themselves contributed to the analysis of their own narratives. The different struggles of each woman occurred within three domains of experience: identity, embodiment, and parenting. They were underpinned by a fluctuation between empowerment and disempowerment. These findings, although based on detailed analysis of the experiences of only three women, dovetail with, integrate, and extend the existent literature, offering a framework for understanding the complexity of meaning making for women. Further research might develop this. The framework may facilitate clinicians’ understandings of what it is like for some women having children who have experienced child sexual abuse.
Abstract.
Barlow A, Phoenix A, Brannen J, Elliott H, Smithson J, Morris P, Smart C (2016). Group Analysis in Practice: Narrative Approaches.
Forum: Qualitative Social Research,
17(2).
Abstract:
Group Analysis in Practice: Narrative Approaches
Working in groups is increasingly regarded as fruitful for the process of analyzing qualitative data. It has been reported to build research skills, make the analytic process visible, reduce inequalities and social distance particularly between researchers and participants, and broaden and intensify engagement with the material. This article contributes to the burgeoning literature on group qualitative data analysis by presenting a worked example of a group data analysis of a short extract from an interview on serial migration from the Caribbean to the UK. It describes the group's working practices and the different analytic resources drawn upon to conduct a narrative analysis. We demonstrate the ways in which an initial line-by-line analysis followed by analysis of larger extracts generated insights that would have been less available to individual researchers. Additionally, we discuss the positioning of group members in relation to the data and reflect on the porous boundary between primary and secondary analysis of qualitative data.
Abstract.
Denman K, Smart C, Dallos R, Levett P (2016). How Families Make Sense of Their Child’s Behaviour When on an Autism Assessment and Diagnosis Waiting List.
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,
46(11), 3408-3423.
Abstract:
How Families Make Sense of Their Child’s Behaviour When on an Autism Assessment and Diagnosis Waiting List
Families waiting for an Autism Spectrum Condition assessment often experience difficulties explaining, or making sense of, the referred young person’s behaviour. Little is known about this sense making, or how clinicians might support this ambiguity. This paper explored finite details of how five families do ‘sense-making’ in conversations with each other, while on the waiting list for an ASC assessment. A Discursive Psychology analysis of these conversations found that sense making was affected by (1) an interactional pattern of interruptions impeding the progress of sense making narratives; (2) face saving to maintain positive identities and shared understanding; and (3) difficulties in word finding within sense making narratives. These practices challenged the production of a coherent family sense making narrative.
Abstract.
Snow K, Cheston R, Smart C (2016). Making sense of dementia: Exploring the use of the Markers of Assimilation of Problematic Experiences in Dementia scale to understand how couples process a diagnosis of dementia.
Dementia,
15(6), 1515-1533.
Abstract:
Making sense of dementia: Exploring the use of the Markers of Assimilation of Problematic Experiences in Dementia scale to understand how couples process a diagnosis of dementia
This qualitative study aimed to see whether the Markers of Assimilation of Problematic Experiences in Dementia (MAPED) scale could be applied to couples. It aimed to explore the interactions between couples and how this affected the levels of assimilation. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with four heterosexual couples. The results suggested that MAPED can be usefully applied to couples. It highlighted the oscillating process which couples undergo as they process a dementia diagnosis. This supports the notion that making sense of a dementia diagnosis is not static, but a fluctuating and ever changing process. The strategies couples employed either facilitated or prevented the expression and integration of the Problematic Voice. The study highlights the importance of supporting couples together during a dementia diagnosis.
Abstract.
Kokkonen TM, Cheston RIL, Dallos R, Smart CA (2014). Attachment and coping of dementia care staff: the role of staff attachment style, geriatric nursing self-efficacy, and approaches to dementia in burnout.
Dementia,
13(4), 544-568.
Abstract:
Attachment and coping of dementia care staff: the role of staff attachment style, geriatric nursing self-efficacy, and approaches to dementia in burnout
Past research suggests that dementia care staff are vulnerable to the development of burnout, which has implications for staff well-being and hence the quality of care for people with dementia. Studying personal vulnerability factors in burnout is important as it can guide staff training and support. Attachment theory suggests that adult attachment styles affect caregiving relationships and individuals’ responses to stress, providing a framework for understanding caregivers’ styles of coping. This cross-sectional survey study examined relationships between staff attachment styles, geriatric nursing self-efficacy, and approaches to dementia in burnout. Seventy-seven members of dementia care staff working on inpatient wards for older people completed self-report questionnaires. Insecure attachment, lower levels of self-efficacy, and more optimistic attitudes in staff were related to higher levels of burnout. Staff training on the role of attachment in dementia care is recommended. Further research is required to explore mediating factors between adult attachment styles and burnout.
Abstract.
Crix D, Stedmon, J (2012). Knowing ‘ME’ Knowing You: the Discursive Negotiation of Contested Illness within a Family. Journal of Depression & Anxiety, 01(04).
Dallos R, Smart C (2011). An exploration of family dynamics and attachment strategies in a family with ADHD/conduct problems.
Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry,
16(4), 535-550.
Abstract:
An exploration of family dynamics and attachment strategies in a family with ADHD/conduct problems
This article reports the preliminary findings of a study of attachment patterns and relationship themes using the TAAI (Transition to Adulthood Attachment Interview), AAI (Adult Attachment Interview) and family interviews (based on the first of 15 families). Research data is presented on a young man aged 16 with a diagnosis of ADHD and his family. Individual interviews, attachment interviews, and family interviews were conducted in order to explore the link between family dynamics, ADHD and attachment strategies. In contrast to findings from existing research indicating pre-occupied patterns for young people diagnosed with ADHD, the young man displayed a complex 'disoriented' attachment pattern which primarily featured a dismissive strategy. However, this was combined with pre-occupied patterns triggered by intrusions from unresolved traumas and memories of his parents' continuing unresolved conflicts. His sense of confusion and lack of a coherent strategy appeared to be closely related to his position of being triangulated into his parents' conflicts. Trans-generational processes were also influential, in that the parents' corrective intentions at more positive parenting were impeded by their own lack of experience of positive attachments in their own childhoods. The study emphasizes the need to consider the relationship between attachment patterns and problems within wider systemic process in the family, in particular triangulation and corrective scripts. © SAGE Publications 2010.
Abstract.
Chapters
Smart C, Reed H (2019). Advocacy for Service Users and Carers in Community Learning Disability Team Meetings When Service Users and Carers Are Absent. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 227-246.
Smart C, Auburn T (2019). Conclusions: Advancing Team Working in Community Mental Health Settings. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 345-357.
Peckitt K, Smart C (2019). Conversation Analysis of Psychological Formulation Discussions in Adult Learning Disabilities Teams. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 147-167.
Smart C, Aikman L, Tremblett M, Dickenson J, Mhlanga S (2019). Healthcare Meetings Where the Service User is Absent: the Ethical and Values-Based Implications for Research. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 57-76.
Auburn T, Smart C, Tremblett M (2019). Inside the Meeting: Discursive Approaches as a Framework for Understanding Multidisciplinary Team Meetings. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 29-55.
Smart C, Dickenson J, Auburn T, Froomberg N (2019). Introduction: Problems and Prospects for Multidisciplinary Team Meetings. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 1-26.
Smart C, Pollock C, Aikman L, Willoughby E (2019). Power Struggles in MDT Meetings: Using Different Orders of Interaction to Understand the Interplay of Hierarchy, Knowledge and Accountability. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 97-121.
Dickenson J, Smart C (2019). Sharing Information and Retelling Stories in a Memory Clinic MDT Meeting. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 209-223.
Smart C, Auburn T (2019). Theorising Multidisciplinary Team Meetings in Mental Health Clinical Practice. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 79-95.
Smart C, Reed H, Sztorc B, Clancy D, Connolly E (2019). Training for Enhanced Team Performance in Mental Healthcare Contexts: a Workshop and its Fit with Interprofessional Care. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 319-343.
Smart C, Reed H, Tremblett M, Froomberg N (2019). Using Joint Conversation Analysis Between Clinicians and Researchers: Developing Reflexivity in Community Mental Health Teams. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 295-317.
Gibson S, Smart C (2017). Social influence. In (Ed) The Palgrave Handbook of Critical Social Psychology, 291-318.
Smart C, Denman K (2017). Student and Supervisor Experiences of Learning and Teaching Conversation Analysis and Discursive Psychology for Autism Spectrum Disorder Focused Research: a Reflective Approach. In (Ed) A Practical Guide to Social Interaction Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders, Palgrave Macmillan UK, 193-217.
Auburn T, Smart C, Santos GH, Annison J, Gilling D (2016). Discovering mental ill health: ‘Problem-solving’ in an english magistrates’ court. In (Ed)
The Palgrave Handbook of Adult Mental Health, 633-652.
Abstract:
Discovering mental ill health: ‘Problem-solving’ in an english magistrates’ court
Abstract.
Dallos R, Smart C, Denman K (2012). Family dynamics, conversations and attachment patterns: the construction of ADHD. In (Ed)
ADHD: Cognitive Symptoms, Genetics and Treatment Outcomes, 35-60.
Abstract:
Family dynamics, conversations and attachment patterns: the construction of ADHD
Abstract.
Publications by year
2022
Smart C, Newman C, Hartill L, Bunce S, McCormick J (2022). Workload effects of online consultation implementation from a Job-Characteristics Model perspective: a qualitative study.
BJGP Open,
7(1), BJGPO.2022.0024-BJGPO.2022.0024.
Abstract:
Workload effects of online consultation implementation from a Job-Characteristics Model perspective: a qualitative study
BackgroundOnline consultation (OC) was previously promoted by the NHS to solve primary care workload challenges. Its implementation was sped up during the COVID-19 pandemic. Workload effects are widely debated. Using a job design perspective may enhance understandings of workload effect.AimTo qualitatively interrogate the workload experiences of primary care staff involved in OC implementation, using the Job Characteristics Model (JCM) to enable the following: a clearer understanding of the primary care staff psychological experiences; and recommendations informing the design of digital implementations and continued use.Design & settingA qualitative interview study of GP practices using OC within South West England.MethodThirteen participants representing seven practices completed JCM-based semi-structured telephone interviews. An abductive theoretically driven thematic analysis was completed.ResultsParticipants experienced different tasks pre- and post-implementation of OC, and adapted differently to them. Differences included the following: contact modality change, some administrative staff felt removed from patient contact; and in perceived autonomy, some GPs valued increased workload control. Variation in workload experience was affected by job role and practice context, and the form of and rationale for implementation. Use of a psychological model (the JCM) allowed clearer consideration of the effects of change, as well as OC on workload.ConclusionPsychological theory may be helpful in interpreting workload effects of technology implementation such as OC. Designing change to include consideration of technology effects, psychological experiences, differences across roles, and individual and practice contexts may be important for technology implementation and evaluation of its workload effects.
Abstract.
MacLeod AM, Smart C, Keohane P, Dallos R, Cox KJ (2022). “We're entitled to be parents just like normal people”: a multiperspective interpretative phenomenological analysis of a mother with a learning disability's experience of parenting following the removal of her older children.
British Journal of Learning Disabilities,
51(3), 368-378.
Abstract:
“We're entitled to be parents just like normal people”: a multiperspective interpretative phenomenological analysis of a mother with a learning disability's experience of parenting following the removal of her older children
AbstractBackgroundDespite a growing body of literature about parents with learning disabilities; there is a paucity of research about experiences of parenting after the removal of a child/children. This study aimed to fill this gap, examining the experiences of that parenting in this context.MethodA multiperspective interpretative phenomenological analysis approach was used. Semistructured interviews were conducted with a parent with a learning disability and three professionals who worked alongside her.FindingsMultiple factors were identified as key changes which enabled the parent to maintain care of her son. The effort from the parent and professionals, understanding of the parent's past experiences and learning disability, and offering her opportunities to develop and illustrate parenting skills were all key to successful parenting after a removal; underpinned by the connection between the parent and professionals.ConclusionFindings highlighted the complex, systemic, and relational nature of these experiences. A formulation‐based approach is needed to support parents with learning disabilities in this context.
Abstract.
2021
Gaussen K, Stedmon J, Smart C (2021). ‘Many pieces one family’: an elaboration of one family’s bereavement experiences. Human Systems Therapy Culture and Attachments, 2(1), 3-19.
2020
Clancy D, Mitchell A, Smart C (2020). A qualitative exploration of the experiences of students attending interprofessional Schwartz Rounds in a University context.
JOURNAL OF INTERPROFESSIONAL CARE,
34(3), 287-296.
Author URL.
Smart C, Page G, Shankar R, Newman C (2020). Keep safe: the when, why and how of epilepsy risk communication.
Seizure,
78, 136-149.
Abstract:
Keep safe: the when, why and how of epilepsy risk communication.
PURPOSE: Risk communication between clinicians and people with epilepsy (PWE) and their families is under researched. There is limited guidance about when and how to have these discussions. This paper explores the current evidence on quality of risk related conversations in epilepsy and suggests a concept of an evidence-based guideline for person centred structured risk communication. METHODS: a literature search of four electronic database, Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase, PUBMED, and CINAHL, was conducted by two independent reviewers using relevant search terms following the principals of the PRISMA guidance. No limits were applied. Supplementary searches included using backwards and forwards citation searching. A predesigned inclusion and exclusion criteria was administered to the identified results. RESULTS: from 376 results identified, 17 studies met the final criteria of which ten were quantitative, five qualitative and two mixed methods. Perspectives of PWE and clinicians were represented. Extracted data was clustered into three domains: communication initiation (e.g. timing, individual tailoring); communication methods (preference for face to face with neurologists); and communication content (acknowledging the anxiety produced by risk communication, the benefits of being self-aware, normalising risk etc.). No papers focused on conversation structure (e.g. helpful phrases), or the best locations to hold conversations. CONCLUSION: More research is needed to develop structured communication of risk. An attempt has been made to put current evidence into this format. Clearer guidance will enhance clinicians' confidence in communicating person centred epilepsy risk with PWE and their families thus improving outcomes.
Abstract.
Author URL.
2019
Smart C, Reed H (2019). Advocacy for Service Users and Carers in Community Learning Disability Team Meetings When Service Users and Carers Are Absent. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 227-246.
Smart C, Auburn T (2019). Conclusions: Advancing Team Working in Community Mental Health Settings. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 345-357.
Peckitt K, Smart C (2019). Conversation Analysis of Psychological Formulation Discussions in Adult Learning Disabilities Teams. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 147-167.
Smart C, Aikman L, Tremblett M, Dickenson J, Mhlanga S (2019). Healthcare Meetings Where the Service User is Absent: the Ethical and Values-Based Implications for Research. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 57-76.
Auburn T, Smart C, Tremblett M (2019). Inside the Meeting: Discursive Approaches as a Framework for Understanding Multidisciplinary Team Meetings. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 29-55.
Smart C, Dickenson J, Auburn T, Froomberg N (2019). Introduction: Problems and Prospects for Multidisciplinary Team Meetings. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 1-26.
Smart C, Pollock C, Aikman L, Willoughby E (2019). Power Struggles in MDT Meetings: Using Different Orders of Interaction to Understand the Interplay of Hierarchy, Knowledge and Accountability. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 97-121.
Dickenson J, Smart C (2019). Sharing Information and Retelling Stories in a Memory Clinic MDT Meeting. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 209-223.
Smart C, Auburn T (2019). Theorising Multidisciplinary Team Meetings in Mental Health Clinical Practice. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 79-95.
Smart C, Reed H, Sztorc B, Clancy D, Connolly E (2019). Training for Enhanced Team Performance in Mental Healthcare Contexts: a Workshop and its Fit with Interprofessional Care. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 319-343.
Smart C, Reed H, Tremblett M, Froomberg N (2019). Using Joint Conversation Analysis Between Clinicians and Researchers: Developing Reflexivity in Community Mental Health Teams. In (Ed) Interprofessional Care and Mental Health, Springer Nature, 295-317.
2018
Quinn C, Byng R, Shenton D, Smart C, Michie S, Stewart A, Taylor R, Maguire M, Harris T, Shaw J, et al (2018). The feasibility of following up prisoners, with mental health problems, after release: a pilot trial employing an innovative system, for engagement and retention in research, with a harder-to-engage population.
Trials,
19(1).
Abstract:
The feasibility of following up prisoners, with mental health problems, after release: a pilot trial employing an innovative system, for engagement and retention in research, with a harder-to-engage population.
BACKGROUND: Following up released prisoners is demanding, particularly for those prisoners with mental health problems, for whom stigma and chaotic lifestyles are problematic. Measurement of mental health outcomes after release is challenging. To evaluate mental healthcare for offender populations, using high-quality randomised controlled trials, evidenced-based methods must be developed to engage them while in custody, to locate and re-interview them after release, and to collect potentially stigmatising mental health outcomes data. METHODS: We developed an initial theoretical model and operational procedures for collecting baseline and follow-up data informed by a literature search, focus groups, and case studies. Male prisoners from five prisons in two sites were invited to participate. The inclusion criteria included individuals who were above threshold on nine-item Patient Health Questionnaire, seven-item Generalized Anxiety Disorder, or post-traumatic stress disorder scales, or who had reported mental health problems in the past 2 years or had been assessed with a likely personality disorder. Potential participants were interviewed to generate baseline data and were re-contacted before their release. We then contacted them for a follow-up interview, which included repeating the earlier data collection measures 2-8 weeks after release. A qualitative formative process evaluation produced and refined a model procedure for the recruitment and retention of male prison leavers in trials, identified the mechanisms which promoted engagement and retention, and mapped these against a theoretical behaviour change model. RESULTS: We developed a flexible procedure which was successful in recruiting male prison leavers to a pilot trial: 185/243 (76%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 70-81%) of those approached agreed to participate. We also retained 63% (95% CI 54-71%) of those eligible to participate in a follow-up interview 2-8 weeks after release. Mental health outcomes data was collected at both these time points. CONCLUSIONS: it is possible to design acceptable procedures to achieve sustained engagement critical for delivering and evaluating interventions in prison and in the community and to collect mental health outcomes data. These procedures may reduce attrition bias in future randomised controlled trials of mental health interventions for prison leavers. This procedure has been replicated and successfully delivered in a subsequent pilot trial and a definitive randomised controlled trial.
Abstract.
Author URL.
Smart C, Froomberg N, Auburn T (2018). What a discursive understanding of interprofessional team meetings might reveal: an exploration of intellectual (learning) disability managers’ performances.
Journal of Interprofessional Care,
32(6), 689-698.
Abstract:
What a discursive understanding of interprofessional team meetings might reveal: an exploration of intellectual (learning) disability managers’ performances
Clinical and academic understandings of interprofessional working are focused mainly on individual factors such as knowledge about different professional roles, and organisational opportunities for interprofessional working (IPW). Less research has examined what happens between people at an interactional level, that is, how interprofessional working is conducted in everyday face-to-face interactions in clinical practice. The current paper proposes a discursive framework for understanding what constitutes IPW in interprofessional meetings at this interactional level. Clinical effectiveness meetings held in intellectual (learning) disability services were used as an example site for IPW. The analysis explored how agenda change points were negotiated, appropriate as agenda change points require collaboration (or agreement) between practitioners to progress to the next point the study found changes in agenda points were accomplished by practitioners conjointly through using discursive strategies including closing questions, and resources such as professional identity and laughter. The agenda provided a frame for the institutional order of the meetings, invoking a trajectory towards timely completion. However, this institutional order was at times subordinated to an ‘order of concern’, which seemed to enable challenges by managers to the meeting Chair and the agenda that demonstrated adherence not only to the procedural nature of the meetings, but also to the needs of service users and the services discussed. We suggest discursive strategies, resources, and both institutional orders, and order of concerns might provide a framework for developing future training and research, that is able to illuminate how IPW might be enacted in face-to-face team meetings.
Abstract.
2017
Gibson S, Smart C (2017). Social influence. In (Ed) The Palgrave Handbook of Critical Social Psychology, 291-318.
Smart C, Denman K (2017). Student and Supervisor Experiences of Learning and Teaching Conversation Analysis and Discursive Psychology for Autism Spectrum Disorder Focused Research: a Reflective Approach. In (Ed) A Practical Guide to Social Interaction Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders, Palgrave Macmillan UK, 193-217.
Byrne J, Smart C, Watson G (2017). “I Felt like I Was Being Abused all over Again”: How Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse Make Sense of the Perinatal Period Through Their Narratives.
Journal of Child Sexual Abuse,
26(4), 465-486.
Abstract:
“I Felt like I Was Being Abused all over Again”: How Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse Make Sense of the Perinatal Period Through Their Narratives
Sequelae following child sexual abuse pervade the lives of adult survivors, significantly impacting on pregnancy and childbirth. Symptoms of this distress are recognized, but meanings for women are less understood. This research aimed to examine the meaning for women themselves of the impact of child sexual abuse on experiences of pregnancy, childbirth, and the postnatal period. Taking a critical feminist perspective, three open-ended interviews with three survivors enabled women’s narratives of pregnancy and childbirth to be heard, explored the structure of these narratives, including how experiences were connected, and identified key themes and how selves and others were positioned. Women themselves contributed to the analysis of their own narratives. The different struggles of each woman occurred within three domains of experience: identity, embodiment, and parenting. They were underpinned by a fluctuation between empowerment and disempowerment. These findings, although based on detailed analysis of the experiences of only three women, dovetail with, integrate, and extend the existent literature, offering a framework for understanding the complexity of meaning making for women. Further research might develop this. The framework may facilitate clinicians’ understandings of what it is like for some women having children who have experienced child sexual abuse.
Abstract.
2016
Auburn T, Smart C, Santos GH, Annison J, Gilling D (2016). Discovering mental ill health: ‘Problem-solving’ in an english magistrates’ court. In (Ed)
The Palgrave Handbook of Adult Mental Health, 633-652.
Abstract:
Discovering mental ill health: ‘Problem-solving’ in an english magistrates’ court
Abstract.
Barlow A, Phoenix A, Brannen J, Elliott H, Smithson J, Morris P, Smart C (2016). Group Analysis in Practice: Narrative Approaches.
Forum: Qualitative Social Research,
17(2).
Abstract:
Group Analysis in Practice: Narrative Approaches
Working in groups is increasingly regarded as fruitful for the process of analyzing qualitative data. It has been reported to build research skills, make the analytic process visible, reduce inequalities and social distance particularly between researchers and participants, and broaden and intensify engagement with the material. This article contributes to the burgeoning literature on group qualitative data analysis by presenting a worked example of a group data analysis of a short extract from an interview on serial migration from the Caribbean to the UK. It describes the group's working practices and the different analytic resources drawn upon to conduct a narrative analysis. We demonstrate the ways in which an initial line-by-line analysis followed by analysis of larger extracts generated insights that would have been less available to individual researchers. Additionally, we discuss the positioning of group members in relation to the data and reflect on the porous boundary between primary and secondary analysis of qualitative data.
Abstract.
Denman K, Smart C, Dallos R, Levett P (2016). How Families Make Sense of Their Child’s Behaviour When on an Autism Assessment and Diagnosis Waiting List.
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,
46(11), 3408-3423.
Abstract:
How Families Make Sense of Their Child’s Behaviour When on an Autism Assessment and Diagnosis Waiting List
Families waiting for an Autism Spectrum Condition assessment often experience difficulties explaining, or making sense of, the referred young person’s behaviour. Little is known about this sense making, or how clinicians might support this ambiguity. This paper explored finite details of how five families do ‘sense-making’ in conversations with each other, while on the waiting list for an ASC assessment. A Discursive Psychology analysis of these conversations found that sense making was affected by (1) an interactional pattern of interruptions impeding the progress of sense making narratives; (2) face saving to maintain positive identities and shared understanding; and (3) difficulties in word finding within sense making narratives. These practices challenged the production of a coherent family sense making narrative.
Abstract.
Snow K, Cheston R, Smart C (2016). Making sense of dementia: Exploring the use of the Markers of Assimilation of Problematic Experiences in Dementia scale to understand how couples process a diagnosis of dementia.
Dementia,
15(6), 1515-1533.
Abstract:
Making sense of dementia: Exploring the use of the Markers of Assimilation of Problematic Experiences in Dementia scale to understand how couples process a diagnosis of dementia
This qualitative study aimed to see whether the Markers of Assimilation of Problematic Experiences in Dementia (MAPED) scale could be applied to couples. It aimed to explore the interactions between couples and how this affected the levels of assimilation. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with four heterosexual couples. The results suggested that MAPED can be usefully applied to couples. It highlighted the oscillating process which couples undergo as they process a dementia diagnosis. This supports the notion that making sense of a dementia diagnosis is not static, but a fluctuating and ever changing process. The strategies couples employed either facilitated or prevented the expression and integration of the Problematic Voice. The study highlights the importance of supporting couples together during a dementia diagnosis.
Abstract.
2014
Kokkonen TM, Cheston RIL, Dallos R, Smart CA (2014). Attachment and coping of dementia care staff: the role of staff attachment style, geriatric nursing self-efficacy, and approaches to dementia in burnout.
Dementia,
13(4), 544-568.
Abstract:
Attachment and coping of dementia care staff: the role of staff attachment style, geriatric nursing self-efficacy, and approaches to dementia in burnout
Past research suggests that dementia care staff are vulnerable to the development of burnout, which has implications for staff well-being and hence the quality of care for people with dementia. Studying personal vulnerability factors in burnout is important as it can guide staff training and support. Attachment theory suggests that adult attachment styles affect caregiving relationships and individuals’ responses to stress, providing a framework for understanding caregivers’ styles of coping. This cross-sectional survey study examined relationships between staff attachment styles, geriatric nursing self-efficacy, and approaches to dementia in burnout. Seventy-seven members of dementia care staff working on inpatient wards for older people completed self-report questionnaires. Insecure attachment, lower levels of self-efficacy, and more optimistic attitudes in staff were related to higher levels of burnout. Staff training on the role of attachment in dementia care is recommended. Further research is required to explore mediating factors between adult attachment styles and burnout.
Abstract.
2012
Dallos R, Smart C, Denman K (2012). Family dynamics, conversations and attachment patterns: the construction of ADHD. In (Ed)
ADHD: Cognitive Symptoms, Genetics and Treatment Outcomes, 35-60.
Abstract:
Family dynamics, conversations and attachment patterns: the construction of ADHD
Abstract.
Crix D, Stedmon, J (2012). Knowing ‘ME’ Knowing You: the Discursive Negotiation of Contested Illness within a Family. Journal of Depression & Anxiety, 01(04).
2011
Dallos R, Smart C (2011). An exploration of family dynamics and attachment strategies in a family with ADHD/conduct problems.
Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry,
16(4), 535-550.
Abstract:
An exploration of family dynamics and attachment strategies in a family with ADHD/conduct problems
This article reports the preliminary findings of a study of attachment patterns and relationship themes using the TAAI (Transition to Adulthood Attachment Interview), AAI (Adult Attachment Interview) and family interviews (based on the first of 15 families). Research data is presented on a young man aged 16 with a diagnosis of ADHD and his family. Individual interviews, attachment interviews, and family interviews were conducted in order to explore the link between family dynamics, ADHD and attachment strategies. In contrast to findings from existing research indicating pre-occupied patterns for young people diagnosed with ADHD, the young man displayed a complex 'disoriented' attachment pattern which primarily featured a dismissive strategy. However, this was combined with pre-occupied patterns triggered by intrusions from unresolved traumas and memories of his parents' continuing unresolved conflicts. His sense of confusion and lack of a coherent strategy appeared to be closely related to his position of being triangulated into his parents' conflicts. Trans-generational processes were also influential, in that the parents' corrective intentions at more positive parenting were impeded by their own lack of experience of positive attachments in their own childhoods. The study emphasizes the need to consider the relationship between attachment patterns and problems within wider systemic process in the family, in particular triangulation and corrective scripts. © SAGE Publications 2010.
Abstract.